In the NFL, when you think of the honor of "Most Valuable Player", what comes to mind? Usually, it's quarterbacks who throw for the most passing yards or touchdowns in a single season (or running backs who break touchdown records).
In the NBA, when you think of the honor of "Most Valuable Player", what comes the mind? Usually, it's the player who leads the league in points, or leads the league in assists with a fair amount of points scored as well.
In MLB, when you think of the "Cy Young", what comes to mind? Usually, it's the player who has the most wins, with a solid earned run average playing the difference in a tiebreaker.
With all of those standards pretty much set in stone, could someone, specifically in the NFL, rewrite those standards one day? Someone like...Joshua Cribbs? Back when Shaun Alexander broke the touchdown record and won the MVP award, did he really do anything overly special? I mean, why are we saying a player is more valuable than everyone else just because the team decided to hand him the ball at the goal line for three-four drives each game when they were already up by two touchdowns? Couldn't any other running back in the league have been inserted into that offense and accomplished the same thing?
When you consider a player like Cribbs though, everything changes. Has a player ever before been able to...
...all at a high level? Granted, by high level, I don't mean he would make a great starting quarterback or a team's No. 1 receiver, but he can certainly throw and catch better than a whole heck of a lot of other players in the league who don't have either quarterback or wide receiver designated as their sole position. When you couple that with the fact that he is perhaps the best player in the NFL in the first four categories, a player of Cribbs' caliber could most definitely set a new standard for the league's most valuable player.
Against the Tennessee Titans, Jamal Lewis couldn't even average one yard per carry against their defensive line. When Cribbs got into the game at quarterback, the direct snap formation allowed Cribbs to find a hole in the defense every time. The Titans defensive line was tentative -- even so to the point where it looked like if he threw a pass, the defensive line would be clueless on how to react.
Then, in the fourth quarter, the Browns finally called a pass play with Cribbs. Calling that play at that point of the game was horrible on Chudzinski's part considering the score, but the play was awe-inspiring nonetheless. Cribbs received the ball in Shotgun and stood there...for what seemed like an infinity compared to the amount of time Ken Dorsey had been receiving. Then, he wound up and threw a better looking deep ball than any of our quarterbacks had thrown all season. In my mind, the play was good enough to have been complete to Braylon Edwards.
This week against the Philadelphia Eagles, reports indicate that Cribbs will again be more involved with the offense. I'm intrigued.
We're not talking about using him like Michael Vick, Vince Young, or Daunte Culpepper. By my assessment, the hype of a full-time quarterback who can run hasn't produced "the answer" to a team's offensive woes. With innovation, that can change...
Last season, Ken Whishenhunt's experiment of giving Matt Leinart a few series to share with Kurt Warner didn't work out too bad. This season, more mobile players have been placed in the backfield, such as Baltimore's Troy Smith and Miami's Ronnie Brown, with significant success. You can go as far as saying that the Dolphins' creative use of Brown is the reason they are currently in position to win their division. And, while Smith hasn't won games for the Ravens, there have been times where he has made a play that could be looked at in hindsight as a difference maker.
Maybe I'm merely thinking in a dream world here, but Joshua Cribbs has the potential to be the most complete player in the NFL (under a new coaching staff). Some people have questioned whether he should be pushed beyond his current workload. Having a guy that is willing to give 110% on kick returns (plays that often involve some of the game's "sickest" collisions), is asking a lot in itself. Do you know what is not asking a lot though?
Being a football player.
If Cribbs can do it all, then let him. If he can be the difference in a sport that is always filled with games decided by three points or less, then let him.
I didn't have time to do my traditional game review of the Titans game, but I'll still leave a few general comments here (note, my Cribbs' essay above is part of the review too)...
We're 2-0 in Monday night games. Against the Eagles, can we improve that mark to 3-0?
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
| 3 | 0 | 0 | 7 | 10 | |
| 3 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 6 | |
Last year, the Cleveland Browns averaged 25 points a game. For our defense to give up just three points in our stadium against the Indianapolis Colts and come away with a loss is shameful. We don't have the most talented group of guys on defense, but every time the unit seems to play a heck of a game (versus Pittsburgh, Washington, Indianapolis), our offense lets them down.
Against Indianapolis, it was even worse. The defense had the lead in the fourth quarter...and they never lost it. They still held -- but all it took to lose the lead was a Derek Anderson turnover for a touchdown. Frustrating.
Let's get started with the goats of the game game balls for Week 13. I always start off with the goats of the game following a loss, but I'm not going to let the offense take away the praise our defense deserves...
Awarding Game Balls (Peyton Manning? Pft...)
Goats of the Game (Bite Me)
General Thoughts (Random Tidbits on the Game)

I can't say the game was a dud like I did in the Texans game two weeks ago. Because Manning and the Colts have a premiere offense, I was so focused and impressed during the game by how well our defense played that I can't say I was bored in the least. Our offense was inept, but they also played a pretty good field position game -- it's just unfortunate that Anderson fumbled in the end.
Up next, we've got the best team in the AFC, the Tennessee Titans, on the road. I'm looking forward to seeing the type of day our defense has against a well-managed Titans offense.
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
| 7 | 6 | 3 | 0 | 16 | |
| 0 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 6 | |
Maybe Brady Quinn shouldn't have played after all against the Houston Texans. After the game, it was revealed that due to playing and practicing with a fractured finger, his injury had worsened to the point where he will miss the remainder of the season.
Even with Quinn's injury, it wasn't a legitimate excuse for the egg the Browns laid against the Texans. For the first time this season, I didn't feel depressed after the game -- I just felt empty. That's a telling sign when you know the season is over.
Let's get started with the goats of the game for Week 12, and there was one player who was especially deserving of one...
Goats of the Game (Hang Your Head)
WR Braylon Edwards cannot hang on to a pass in the end zone from QB Derek Anderson. The catch would've made it a 16-13 game with enough time left to play.Awarding Game Balls (Solid in Defeat)
General Thoughts (Random Tidbits on the Game)
If you were frustrated by the Browns' effort this season, here is some good news: you'll get to watch Derek Anderson for the rest of the season!
The Browns should have run the ball more with Jamal Lewis, if for nothing more than to take pressure off of Quinn.The game was a dud, plain and simple. I tried to avoid talking too much about Romeo Crennel's decisions in this game, because it's obvious that what he did was just as bad as what Andy Reid did with Donovan McNabb against the Baltimore Ravens.
Against Indianapolis, we'll be facing one of the hottest teams in the AFC. We've only won one game at home this year, but it's not time to throw the towel in. We defeated Peyton Manning's brother, Eli Manning, and the New York Giants earlier this year, proving that wonders can happen on any given Sunday (unless you're the Detroit Lions). Also, I haven't forgotten about last season. And neither should you have. What needs to be in store this Sunday for the Browns?
Revenge.
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
| 6 | 7 | 3 | 13 | 29 | |
| 0 | 10 | 3 | 14 | 27 | |
The Browns won for the third time in their past four road games, taking out the wildcard-contending Buffalo Bills 29-27 on Monday Night Football. It was our second Monday Night victory of the season in two attempts -- we have one more in December against the Philadelphia Eagles.
I think that overall, when you look at the state of the team, we are a better football team than last season. Looking at our schedule heading into the season, we feared that despite being better, we'd have a worse record. We do have a worse record at this point (4-6), but it's not because of the competition. We've defeated the defending Super Bowl Champion New York Giants. We've defeated two potential playoff teams in Buffalo and Jacksonville. And, we dominated the Denver Broncos and Baltimore Ravens -- two teams with great records -- until making team history with collapses.
The odds aren't in our favor now, but we still love Cleveland Browns football, and our team gave us another wild one against Buffalo. Let's get started with the game balls for Week 11...
Awarding Game Balls (Making Fans Jump for Joy)
Goats of the Game (Could Have Cost Us)
General Thoughts (Random Tidbits on the Game)
The defense was horrible again in the fourth quarter, meaning our "rotations" didn't really keep people any fresher. In the end, the "W" is what matters, and Brady Quinn has improved to a .500 record at 1-1. This is the third straight game that we should have blown out the competition based on how we started the games; maybe we can do that this Sunday against the Texans. Thank goodness for a regular Sunday 1:00 PM game too -- I've missed those.
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
| 7 | 3 | 3 | 21 | 34 | |
| 7 | 13 | 3 | 7 | 30 | |
Show hope. Insert dagger. Twist.
There hasn't been a more painful stretch in a span of five days since the Browns returned to the NFL. After having a two-possession lead in two home games late in the game, we came away with two losses. Our record should be 5-4, right in the thick of the wildcard and divison playoff race. Instead, we're 3-6, with our only playoff hopes coming down to going undefeated the rest of the way. That isn't going to happen.
The offense played very well in the debut of Brady Quinn as the team's starting quarterback. Considering the fact that we played a conservative gameplan and scored 30 points, that definitely adds to the excitement he'll provide this team in the future. Right now, the concerns shift back to the defensive side of the ball. They are at the forefront of this week's goats...
Goats of the Game (Unbelievably Bad)
Awarding Game Balls (Gold Stars to Put on Their Locker Door)

General Thoughts (Random Tidbits on the Game)

The Brady Quinn era should not have started with a loss. In post-game press conferences, he played the leader role by taking the blame, but everyone knows that the defense was atrocious. We've got the Buffalo Bills up next after what ends up being a "second bye week", and we'd like to make some changes on the defensive depth chart. But...what can you really change?
Terry Cousin over Brandon McDonald?
Nice depth. Oh, yeah...and real playoff contenders -- the Washington Redskins and the New York Jets -- just signed DeAngelo Hall and Ty Law, respectively.
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
| 10 | 3 | 7 | 17 | 37 | |
| 7 | 6 | 14 | 0 | 27 | |
Last season, the only game I chose not to do a game review for was the season finale, a game in which the Cleveland Browns defeated the San Francisco 49ers. All of the anticipation following that game was on the Indianapolis Colts vs. Tennessee Titans contest -- and after how depressed Cleveland fans felt after seeing the Colts roll over and die in that game, it didn't feel worth going back and analyzing our game.
Similarly, I didn't really feel like analyzing the loss to the Baltimore Ravens this past Sunday for several reasons. First off, its a short week, and we need to get prepared for tomorrow's game against the Denver Broncos. Second, with the team announcing QB Brady Quinn as the team's new starting quarterback, the direction of the team from the Ravens game should be much different than the direction of the team against Denver.
Nonetheless, I'm sure some of you were still looking forward to a review. With it being a little more brief than usual, let's get started with the goats this week...
Goats of the Game (We Hate Them This Week)
Awarding Game Balls (Gold Stars to Put on Their Locker Door)
General Thoughts (Random Tidbits on the Game)
QB Derek Anderson watches as the Ravens put the nail in the coffin in regards to the game and his starting quarterback role.The Derek Anderson era is over for now -- and I do say that as somewhat of a cliffhanger, because starting quarterbacks go down with injuries all the time. Quinn is the new leader of this team though, and I'm sure he's ready to inject some life back into the offense.
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
| 7 | 10 | 0 | 6 | 23 | |
| 0 | 7 | 7 | 3 | 17 | |
Ignoring the Ravens game in which Anderson skewed the number of points our defense allowed, these are the point totals we've given up as of late: 10 points (Pittsburgh), 12 points (Cincinnati), 14 points (New York Giants), 14 points (Washington), and 17 points (Jacksonville).
Three of those opponents are currently ranked in the top four of most peoples' power rankings. In other words, nearly half-way through the season, it should be official: the defense has exceeded expectations this season. We've exceeded expectations without productivity from Corey Williams or our linebackers. We've exceeded expectations without Robaire Smith and Shaun Smith being available.
Most importantly, we've exceeded expectations because of one player -- Shaun Rogers. He'll most certainly kick off the game balls this week after the type of game he had...
Awarding Game Balls (It Means They Did Good!)
Goats of the Game (Failed Efforts in Victory)
General Thoughts (Random Tidbits on the Game)
If WR Matt Jones had come down with this catch, our wildcard hopes would have instantly taken a massive hit.At 3-4 with a division game this week against the Baltimore Ravens, the Browns are back on the right track. The margin for error is still very slim though, and with two games in a span of five days coming up, it'll be critical that Derek Anderson is on the top of his game. That's taking a leap of faith, but Crennel isn't going to make a change during that stretch. We'll either be 5-4, 4-5, or 3-6 when it's all said and done. Anderson can survive the first two records, but not the third.
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
| 0 | 0 | 3 | 8 | 11 | |
| 0 | 0 | 7 | 7 | 14 | |
After Sunday's loss to the Washington Redskins, clearly there is only one man to blame: Phil Dawson. Only kidding, of course, as it was clearly the underachieving offense that cost us yet another football game.
Just think about that -- the Browns, potential-wise, are supposed to have one of the best offenses in football.
We held one of the AFC's best teams, Pittsburgh, to just 10 points. Result? Loss.
We held one of the NFC's best teams, Washington, to just 14 points. Result? Loss.
This week, it wasn't the playcalling that was the problem. The adjustments that Rob Chudzinski has made over the past several weeks were still on display. However, if you can't even execute a screen pass to a receiver at the line of scrimmage, you can't move the chains to set up the remainder of your gameplan as a coordinator. The goats of the game this week are back again, and although a major case can be made for two of our players on offense getting the award, I'm going to substitute one of them for a defensive player.
Goats of the Game (The Reason We're Not .500)
Awarding Game Balls (Fewer Than Last Week)
General Thoughts (Random Tidbits on the Game)
Believe it or not, the Redskins game was losable. It kills me that we didn't seize the advantage and get back to .500, but we still showed that we can compete with a very good football team, even on the road, until the final seconds.
The bigger game comes this week against the Jacksonville Jaguars. Why were we left out of the postseason last year? Because we had a horrible conference record in comparison to Tennessee.
Right now, we're only one game back of a tie for the wildcard. One game! That is no reason to give up hope. The Jaguars will be competing for one of those wildcard spots though, so if we can take them out this weekend, that will be a huge step forward in getting our season back on track.
Showing 1 - 8 of 16 Older